Home › Compare › P11D software for expenses and benefits
P11D and benefits software, which is not payroll
These handle expenses and benefits returns. They sit on the same HMRC list and are easy to buy by mistake when what you need is payroll.
| Product | Supplier | Pricing | Their page |
|---|---|---|---|
| Easy Cloud Payroll P11D | 1 2 Cloud Payroll | No pricing found | Supplier |
| Easy Cloud Bureau Payroll P11D | 1 2 Cloud Payroll | No pricing found | Supplier |
| Professional P11D | 12efile | No pricing found | Supplier |
| Andica P11D Software Expenses | Andica Limited | No pricing found | Supplier |
| P11D Enterprise | BDO LLP | No pricing found | Supplier |
| P11D submission pro | DC Software | No pricing found | Supplier |
| KPMG P11D Solutions | KPMG LLP | No pricing found | Supplier |
| Payroo P11D Professional | Payroo | No pricing found | Supplier |
| P11D Organiser | Personal Audit Systems Ltd | Quote only | Pricing |
| Sage 50 P11D | Sage (UK) Ltd | Could not check | Supplier |
| Taxshield P11D Manager | Shield Products, trading as Taxshield | No pricing found | Supplier |
| Taxshield P11D Manager | Taxshield | No pricing found | Supplier |
What the pricing column means
There is no price on this page, and that is deliberate. We tried reading prices off supplier pages automatically and got about half of them wrong: a customer testimonial became one supplier’s price, a promotional first-six-months rate became another’s, and a sentence about what accountants charge became a third’s. The methodology sets out exactly what went wrong. So the column reports the one thing we can establish reliably, which is whether the supplier is willing to tell you the price before you talk to a salesperson.
Across the whole HMRC list, 17 of 177 products come from suppliers who publish a price and 48 do not. The transparency report has the detail.
Other lists
Source: HMRC’s recognised payroll software list, under the Open Government Licence, plus each supplier’s own published pages. Inclusion is never paid for. We are not accountants and this is not advice about which product suits your business.